Content
is hard to scale, and one of the reasons why MMOs have it so hard
source:
Wiki Commons public domain image
|
Hello, all. I'm Chris Bell, and this is my new gaming blog. The content will primarily be aimed at RPGs - paper and pencil for the most part, but with a lot of coverage in the MMO, single player and mobile spaces. I'll also be covering my thoughts on marketing, community management and how to sell and develop games. Generally, I'll work to talk about what's good and how I feel we can make things better. Because, let's face it - it's very easy to bitch and be cynical. My man Henry Rollins talks about this in depth. Cynicism is the height of intellectual and moral cowardice. Want to make the world better? Reach out a hand and build - don't tear down. #whatareyoubuilding?
But today I'll be talking about massively multiplayer online games, or MMOs, and the content crisis they now face. The shine has worn off the MMO apple, and what was once the apple of investor's eyes is now turny wormy, with declining sub rates and dissatisfaction all around.
Over the past few years,
we've seen subscriber rates drop for MMO style games drop - World of Warcraft
from a peak of 12 million subscriptions in 2009 to 7.4 million in 2014
according to Statista. Other
MMOs have reported similar losses.
Extra Credit have with their excellent online video series gone into this issue
in much better detail than I could,but what I feel is the beating heart and
soul of the problem is that publishers are failing because they simply don't
want to face what they know deep down is the real issue - to paraphrase Harlan
Ellison, they don't want to pay the writer (or in this case, the Creative.) Let me explain:
In traditional
capitalism, companies use technology to make money by what is known as economies of scale. This means that if I invest
in a machine that makes shoes, I may have to invest in a lot of money in a
machine that makes shoes once, but since this machine can make the same set of
identical shoes the same way over and over again. All you need to do is to
build that machine once, and spend a much smaller amount of money to maintain
that machine (and some labor dollars to operate it.) This is called capital investment.
In terms of MMOs,
capital investment would be buying SDKs, creating server software, developing
art and story assets, and so on. The problem however in all creative investment
is that both software and creative assets have very short shelf lives. There
have been games that have entire libraries of art assets that costs millions of
dollars to develop that had to be abandoned due to platforms they were designed
for becoming obsolete. This is a problem faced in movies, TV and film - media
has a very short shelf life.
Now, for a while, it
seemed as if MMOs had this problem licked. Content development is very
expensive, as writers, programmers and artists must be paid living wages for
their considerable skills. MMOs became part of a larger and larger trend of user generated content where developers tried to simply create
sandboxes where players would fill in the blanks for content and where less
labor-hours would need to be spent on actual storytelling and on things that
tech-oriented business people who ran these studios would feel more comfortable
with - code, engines, rendering, graphics. Keep the story elements vague and
diffuse, and focus on the action. Hey, Call of Duty is making the money, so
they must be doing something right, right?
However, things started
coming to a head. Tensions inside the MMO community between PVE raiders and PVP
gamers started to grow, with an entirely new genre being born (MOBAS, which
emphasize competitive play and seem to be the e-sport which WOW was trying to
achieve via WOW Arena). Raiding became harder and harder and more exclusionary
to casuals, who, ironically, are necessary to an MMOs success. It's almost as
if a culture war of sorts, between players who wanted pure game play dressed up
in whatever genre dressings they liked in a tug of war with those who wanted
deep plot lines and grand drama (and who regard deep game play and challenge as
distracting). Caught in the middle were both the casual gamer and the
developers who wanted to serve all 3 constituencies, since all of these
concerns are legitimate and, indeed, vital to each other for great MMO games.
It all sums up to this -
art and writing is expensive, and is what people pay for and come to see.
Business people hate that you can't mass produce dreams and ideas. This is part
of why we see sequels so much - sequels and reboots are the creative versions
of economies of scale. They're the artistic version of mass production. And
before anyone accuses me of raging against the machine, let me point out that
it's risky to produce new and original content. 8 out of 10 movies fail, and
the two that succeed for major studios pay for all the flops. Those two are
usually reboots and sequels. Reboots and sequels work. You can't fault investors for that.
In the wake of all this, Nintendo's recent announcements at
E3 seem to indicate a strong return to support "the single player experience." This fills me with a lot of hope. You
see, by emphasizing things that are more mechanical (game play, sand box play,
group play, user generated content) there was a conscious decision by
what is a creative industry to shy away from being creative. Being creative means making tough decisions in regards to creative
issues. Also, there are a lot of changes happening in the gaming space with new
demographics of gamers - women, people of color, folks with disabilities -
demanding representation with their dollars. It's easier when designing marketing and
content plans to focus on technical things like user generated content,
hardware platforms and game play than, say, worrying about how your paying
audience is changing because world wide gaming demographics are shifting and
you as a developer are going to need to change your storytelling and character
designs to reflect that - with audiences from situations that you didn't grow
up in and are not familiar with.
As a casual gamer,
creative, and marketer, here's what I think would be good roads for the gaming
industry to go down -
- Pay the creative. No, really. Good storytelling, character designs, a
compelling narrative, a great world - these outlive platforms or even
gameplay formats. This is brand development. Legendary brands in gaming
such as Street Fighter, Mass Effect and Halo derive their strength from
compelling narratives. While a game like Go is brilliance in game play, we
get excited about the personal drama about the hero of the Hikaru No Go
manga as he masters the game.
- Storytelling should be the basis of all great game
design. This holds just as true
for competitive and co-op team games as it does for single player gaming.
Gaming experiences need to hold meaning and decisions need to matter.
Bioware are the absolute masters of this method of game design.
- Great games are a conversation. This is really, really hard. Having been a veteran of
the RPG scene for decades, I can tell you that many designers would simply
publish and only take their fans money and not directly interact with
their customers. This is a huge mistake. Especially in the wake of controversies like Gamergate,
engaging in public relations and social media with one's fan base in this
day is hugely daunting, but designers and studios who can pull this off
will win - not only in terms of popularity and sales, but also in terms of
designing better products and making gaming better. In a later article
I'll share my thoughts on gaming, pr and marketing.